Catering Menu
Welcome!
How to order
Please read over our catering menu carefully. Your questions may be answered. If you are ready to order, or if you have additional questions, please start out by emailing us at nonnaspantry1@gmail.com or calling us at 616-920-7377 and a catering guide will be in touch with you within 1 business day to assist you further. Please note all catering orders require a minimum of three business days of notice. If you want to discuss in person, please email FIRST to make an appointment to speak with a knowledgable staff member. We cannot guarantee a member of staff will be available to speak with drop-in in-person requests.
Disclaimer: Please note that due to shifting market conditions, price are subject to change without notice. Thank you for your understanding.
If there are dietary restrictions, allergies or concerns our aim is to be accommodating wherever possible.
Boxes
Some boxes may be available same day, but we cannot guarantee this. Please call ahead to order.
Breakfast Pastry Box.......... $52
- 4 cinnamon rolls
- 4 scones
- 4 muffins
- 4 daily feature muffins/coffee cake
*Without a full 48 hours of notice, the above selections cannot be guaranteed and may be substituted with other pastries.*
Cookie Box and Party Platter.......... $38-$55
- Party Platter: $55 — 30 mini bars; chef’s choice variety of 3 types of mini bars
- May include: salted brown butter Rice Krispy treats, brownies, blondies, lemon bars, pecan bars, chocolate walnut espresso bars, pie bars, seven layer bars, or oatmeal lemon cream bars (not all bars are available at all times; the mix is a chef’s choice but customers may make requests and with enough notice, choices may be able to be accommodated)
- 24 mini cookies: $38
- 2 dozen full size cookies: $55
- Choose from: salted chocolate chip, peanut butter, oatmeal raisin, double ginger molasses, snickerdoodle, Strega Nonna, coconut macaroon (GF) or M&M
Lunch Box.......... $15
- Nonna sandwich (flavor options based on our seasonal rotating menu) or chicken salad or egg salad with GF crackers
- 8oz deli salad
- fresh cookie
- (serves 1)
8-12 Person Meals
- Minimum notice 3 business days
- Pricing is for pre-orders only
- All orders must be prepaid
- Sides not included (Regular sides $9 / Premium sides $14)
- Sides serve 3-4
Suggested sides: Rainbow roasted vegetables and Caesar salad
Meatloaf $45
Suggested sides: Nonna mashed potatoes and kale salad
Nonna’s Classic Lasagna or Greek Lasagna (Pasticio) $65
Suggested sides: Herbed focaccia and Nonna salad
Italian Meatballs with House Marinara $48
25 meatballs
Suggested sides: Seasonal risotto or parmesan pasta and Caesar salad
Pork or Chicken Enchiladas (15) $72
Beef Enchiladas (15) $75
Suggested sides: Yellow rice and side of queso
Pulled BBQ Chicken $14 (per pound/ one pound serves 3-4 OR 5lbs for $65)
Suggested Sides: House biscuits and calico beans
Herb Roasted Chicken with Sour Cream and Onion Smashed Potatoes (GF) or Peruvian Chicken with Cilantro Lime Rice and Green Sauce (GF) $65
2 whole chickens cut into 4 pieces – 8 pieces total
Suggested sides: Kale salad
Maryland Crab Cakes (GF) $50 for 6 cakes, $100 for 12 cakes, $9 for each additional
Served with Lemon Aioli on a bed of mixed greens
Suggested side: Seasonal Risotto (GF,V) and mashed sweet potato (GF, Vegan)
Serves 6-8
See menu page for more information on our featured quiche favorites
Suggested sides: Cinnamon rolls, Merry Berry scones and Nonna salad
Desserts
Banana Pudding with whipped cream and cookies (serves 4-6 or 8-12) $16 or $30
Beverages
1/2 gallon Nonna cold brew $21
1/2 gallon Nonna iced tea $16.50
1/2 gallon seasonal drink special $MP
Brewed coffee tote $32
Coffee tote with bakers dozen $65
- Ask about pricing on available packaged soft drinks, sparkling waters, kombucha and juices
- Add cups and ice for $.30 each